What’s that saying? “You can never go home again?”
We’re leaving for Winnipeg this afternoon for a short visit. There is a big family gathering, a celebration of my brother’s wedding earlier this summer. My kids are going to be spoiled with attention. It will be wonderful to see everyone — I come from a big family, lots of cousins, aunts, uncles, etc. But at the end of these visit, I always wonder — could I ever come back home?
Winnipeg is home. I return to it all the time in my writing. There have been times where I have wondered whether I will ever be able to write about any other place. I have such a love/hate relationship with the city. And largely this relationship is wrapped up in the guilt I feel for leaving.
How ridiculous is that? I feel guilting for moving away — the best decision I ever could have made — as if I have abandoned a child in the process. My mother has a way of updating me on everyone who makes the decision to come “back home.”
“So-and-so has decided to move back from Vancouver. She really wants to put roots down here.”
“So-and-so is coming back to teach at the university. Because, you know, family is such a big draw.”
And there in lies the guilt. If I have decided not to settle in Winnipeg, then I have abandoned not only a city, but my entire family, and its history, so strongly rooted there. I’ve broken the chain of Ludwig/Donens who have lived in Winnipeg now for four generations. And to make matters worse, I’ve decided to live in Toronto, which means I am raising two Torontonians, a word many Winnipeggers use with disdane.
It’s silly, really. Because everyone makes their life choices for very specific reasons. For me, Winnipeg can never be home again because it does not have the religious options I want in a community. And while there are many, many things I miss about the city (the size, the accessible arts, the festivals), it’s not enough to bring me home for longer than an extended vacation.
So I’m really looking forward to this trip. Family dynamics are wonderful fuel for books. And I love showing off my childhood home to my kids. But that’s all it is. My home is the life I have decided to build elsewhere.